How to Teach French Subjunctive vs. Indicative – A French Teacher’s Guide

How to Teach French Subjunctive vs. Indicative - A French Teacher's Guide

How to Teach French Subjunctive vs. Indicative – A French Teacher’s Guide

When I teach the French subjunctive, one of the biggest challenges is not actually forming the subjunctive.

It’s knowing when to use it.

Students can learn the conjugations of être, avoir, faire, aller, and other common verbs, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they know when a sentence calls for the subjunctive instead of the indicative.

That’s why I like to teach subjunctive vs. indicative through expressions.

Rather than asking students to memorize every possible sentence that requires the subjunctive, I have them look at the meaning of the expression before que.

I use a simple framework to help them recognize the most common categories: WEIRDO.

W — Wishing / wanting
E — Emotion
I — Impersonal expressions
R — Request / require / recommend
D — Doubt / demand / deny
O — Opinions

This gives students a way to organize a long list of subjunctive expressions and, more importantly, gives them something to look for when they’re trying to decide which mood to use.

French Present Subjunctive Reference Guide – Foldable Handout Book

Looking for more resources to help you teach the French subjunctive vs. indicative? Scroll down to the section at the end of this post to see my ready-to-use resources for this topic.



Start with the basic difference between subjunctive and indicative

I first remind students that the present subjunctive can refer to the present or the future.

If your students need a lesson on how to recognize and form the present subjunctive, see my guide to teaching the French present subjunctive.

The important thing is not simply whether we’re talking about the past, present, or future.

Instead, I want students to pay attention to the relationship between the main clause and the dependent clause.

When the sentence contains a dependent clause introduced by que, I have students look at the expression in the main clause.

Is it expressing something subjective, such as a desire, emotion, doubt, necessity, or opinion?

If so, the subjunctive may be required.

I then contrast that with expressions that present something as a statement, observation, certainty, belief, or other indication of what the speaker considers to be true.

This is where the indicative comes in.


Teach students to look at the expression before que

This is the habit I want students to develop.

Instead of immediately looking at the verb after que, I have them look at what comes before que.

For example:

Il est possible que demain il fasse beau.

The expression il est possible que introduces something that is possible rather than certain, so I use the subjunctive.

Compare that with:

Il est certain que le soleil se lèvera demain.

Here, il est certain que expresses certainty, so I use the indicative.

The two sentences have a very similar structure.

The difference is the expression that introduces the dependent clause.


Introduce the WEIRDO framework

This is where I give students a way to organize the expressions they need to recognize.

W — Wishing and wanting

Expressions of wishing and wanting require the subjunctive.

For example:

Je voudrais que tu viennes avec moi.

I want you to come with me.

Je souhaite que tous mes enfants soient heureux.

I wish happiness for all my children.

I point out that je voudrais means “I would like,” so it expresses wanting.

I want students to start recognizing the meaning of the expression rather than simply memorizing the sentence.

E — Emotion

The next category is emotion.

For example:

Je suis ravi(e) que tu aies pris le temps pour venir me voir.

I am delighted that you took the time to come see me.

I point out that je suis ravi(e) expresses an emotion.

There doesn’t necessarily have to be doubt in the sentence.

That’s an important point for students to understand.

Emotion itself is enough to put us into this category.

I also use:

Je suis désolé(e) que tu aies eu une journée difficile.

I’m sorry you’ve had a tough day.

And:

Je regrette que tu ne puisses pas nous accompagner.

I’m sorry you can’t come with us.

These examples help students see that the emotion can take many different forms.

I — Impersonal expressions

The next category is impersonal expressions.

For example:

Il est important que tu me comprennes.

It’s important that you understand me.

The expression il est important que is impersonal, and it requires the subjunctive.

I also introduce:

Il est dommage qu’elle n’ait pas été acceptée à la faculté de médecine.

It’s a shame she wasn’t accepted into medical school.

And:

Il vaut mieux que cette histoire reste entre nous.

It’s best to keep this story between us.

I want students to start recognizing these expressions as structures that naturally lead them toward the subjunctive.

R — Requests, requirements, and recommendations

Next comes requests, requirements, and recommendations.

For example:

Je suggère que tu te fasses un emploi du temps.

I suggest that you make yourself a schedule.

The expression je suggère que is a recommendation, so the subjunctive follows.

Another useful example is:

Je propose que nous discutions de tes projets pour l’avenir.

I suggest we discuss your plans for the future.

And:

Il faut que tu finisses tes devoirs avant de sortir.

You need to finish your homework before going out.

I also point out something useful about il faut.

Students can use:

Il faut que + subject + subjunctive

but they can also use il faut + infinitive.

For example:

Il te faut prendre le dernier train.

This is useful because students can see that there are times when they can express the same basic idea without creating a subjunctive clause.

D — Doubt, demands, and denying

The D category includes expressions involving doubt, demands, and denying.

For example:

Je ne crois pas que la banque soit encore ouverte.

I don’t believe the bank is still open.

The expression je ne crois pas que expresses doubt, so the subjunctive follows.

I also use:

Je ne pense pas que le chien ait mangé mes devoirs.

I don’t think the dog ate my homework.

This is a particularly useful pair for students because they already know je crois que and je pense que.

That gives us an opportunity to compare the positive and negative forms.

O — Opinions

The final category is opinions.

This is an area where I want students to pay particularly close attention to whether the expression is affirmative or negative.

For example:

Je crois que le café est absolument indispensable pour bien démarrer la journée.

I believe that coffee is absolutely essential to start the day.

Here, je crois que is affirmative, so I use the indicative.

Compare that with:

Je ne crois pas que la banque soit encore ouverte.

I don’t believe the bank is still open.

The negative expression leads to the subjunctive.

I also give students:

Je pense que…

versus:

Je ne pense pas que…

This comparison is much more useful than simply telling students to memorize that croire or penser “takes the subjunctive.”


Show students that some expressions come in pairs

This is one of my favorite ways to practice the distinction.

I put expressions side by side and ask students to notice what changes.

Je crois que… → indicative

Je ne crois pas que… → subjunctive

Je pense que… → indicative

Je ne pense pas que… → subjunctive

For example:

Je crois que le café est absolument indispensable.

I believe that coffee is absolutely essential.

Je ne crois pas que le chien ait mangé mes devoirs.

I don’t think the dog ate my homework.

I also point out that a question can change the situation:

Croyez-vous qu’il veuille venir ?

Do you think he wants to come?

This gives students a chance to see that they need to pay attention to the meaning and structure of the whole expression, not just memorize a verb.

Once students understand when to use the subjunctive, you can also introduce the past subjunctive. See my guide to teaching the French past subjunctive for ideas on how to teach this next step.


Give students a list of common indicative expressions too

I don’t want this lesson to become a list of things that “trigger the subjunctive.”

Students also need to recognize expressions that are followed by the indicative.

I use examples such as:

Il est certain que…

Il est probable que…

Je crois que…

Je pense que…

J’observe que…

J’affirme que…

Je suppose que…

J’espère que…

Je trouve que…

Je sais que…

Je remarque que…

Je constate que…

J’imagine que…

Il est clair que…

Il est sûr que…

For example:

Je suppose que tu as déjà fini ton travail puisque tu es parti si tôt.

I guess you’ve already finished your work since you left so early.

And:

Je sais que demain sera une journée chargée.

I know tomorrow will be a busy day.

I want students to understand that learning the subjunctive also means learning to recognize when not to use it.


Introduce expressions that automatically require the subjunctive

Once students are comfortable with the main WEIRDO categories, I add some expressions that they simply need to recognize.

For example:

jusqu’à ce que

until

à condition que

provided that / as long as

avant que

before

en attendant que

while waiting for

pour que

so that

afin que

so that

For example:

Je continuerai à appeler jusqu’à ce que vous me disiez d’arrêter.

I’ll keep calling until you tell me to stop.

And:

Je viendrai à condition que Jean ne soit pas là.

I’ll come as long as Jean isn’t there.

I also teach:

Avant que + ne explétif

For example:

Laisse-moi préparer du thé avant que tu (ne) me racontes ta journée.

Let me make some tea before you tell me about your day.

This is a good point to introduce the ne explétif because students will encounter it in this particular structure.


Point out expressions that don’t need the subjunctive

I also want students to recognize that some structures can be followed by an infinitive instead.

For example:

Je veux venir, mais pas si Jean est là.

I want to come, but not if Jean is there.

And:

J’aimerais te voir heureux.

I’d like to see you happy.

Here, the subject of the main verb and the infinitive is understood to be the same, so there is no need to create a separate que clause.

This gives students another useful question to ask themselves:

Do I actually need a second subject and a que clause?

If not, an infinitive may be possible.


Teach après que as an important contrast

One expression I specifically point out is:

après que

After.

For example:

Après que j’ai vu ce film, j’ai fondu en larmes.

After I saw this film, I broke down in tears.

I include this because students often want to group après que with expressions such as avant que, but the structures are not the same in this lesson.

The point I want students to remember is simply:

avant que → subjunctive

après que → indicative


Give students a simple decision-making process

Once we’ve gone through the expressions, I have students use a process instead of trying to remember an enormous list.

I ask them:

Is there a que clause?

If yes, look at the expression before que.

What does that expression communicate?

Is it:

W — wishing or wanting?

E — emotion?

I — an impersonal expression?

R — a request, requirement, or recommendation?

D — doubt, demand, or denying?

O — an opinion?

If so, the subjunctive may be required.

If the expression communicates certainty, belief, observation, knowledge, or another indicative idea, I have students consider the indicative instead.

The goal isn’t for students to memorize the word WEIRDO and then stop thinking.

The goal is for WEIRDO to give them a starting point for recognizing the meaning of the expression.


Make the lesson practical with sentence pairs

After students have learned the categories, I like to give them pairs or groups of sentences and have them decide which mood they need.

For example:

Il est possible que demain il fasse beau.

The weather may be fine tomorrow.

versus:

Il est certain que le soleil se lèvera demain.

It’s certain that the sun will rise tomorrow.

Or:

Je souhaite que tu réussisses dans tout ce que tu entreprends.

I wish you success in everything you undertake.

versus:

J’affirme que le succès vient souvent de la persévérance et de la détermination.

I maintain that success often comes from perseverance and determination.

This kind of practice forces students to focus on meaning, which is exactly what they need to do when deciding between the subjunctive and indicative.


I don’t try to make students memorize every expression at once

There are a lot of expressions associated with the French subjunctive.

I don’t expect students to memorize one enormous list and somehow know how to use all of it immediately.

Instead, I give them categories first.

Then I add common expressions.

Then I practice those expressions in context.

And as students encounter more French, they gradually add more expressions to the ones they already recognize.

The WEIRDO framework gives them somewhere to put those new expressions when they encounter them.


I use my comprehensive resource for the full lesson

This is one of those topics where I think a short blog post can give teachers a teaching approach, but a more comprehensive resource is useful when they actually want to teach the entire lesson.

I’ve created a much more comprehensive French Subjunctive vs. Indicative resource that goes well beyond this overview. It includes the expressions, explanations, examples, and practice that I use to help students understand when to choose the subjunctive and when to choose the indicative.

If you’re looking for something you can actually use with your students rather than creating all of these examples and practice activities yourself, this is the resource I would use alongside this lesson.

French Subjunctive vs. Indicative Lesson – Advanced / AP French


Ready to Practice French Subjunctive vs. Indicative?

If your students are ready to practice choosing between the French subjunctive and indicative, here are some other practice resources:

French Subjunctive vs. Indicative – PowerPoint Jeopardy Game

French Subjunctive vs. Indicative – Google Forms Quiz or Exercise

French Reading Comprehension Quiz – Subjunctive vs. Indicative

COMPLETE FRENCH CURRICULUM SEQUENCE

Share it:

Email
Facebook
Pinterest
X

Get Your 100 French Speaking Cards!

FREE RESOURCE FOR FRENCH TEACHERS

Help your students speak French with confidence! Get 100 French speaking cards you can use with your students at any level, plus my weekly newsletter with practical teaching ideas and classroom strategies.

French Teacher Newsletter Free French Speaking Cards

Featured French Courses

Comprehensive French courses geared toward English speakers